OR WAIT 15 SECS
Far more people have heard of Tourette syndrome than know what it actually looks and sounds like - or how it feels to the person who has it. That's a major reason the diagnosis of this condition - the most severe tic disorder - is often missed. This is part one of a two-part series. See Tourette syndrome--Much more than tics, part 2: Management
First of two parts
|Jump to:||Choose article section...|
Far more people have heard of Tourette syndrome than know what it actually looks and sounds likeor how it feels to the person who has it. That's a major reason the diagnosis of this conditionthe most severe tic disorderis often missed. A change of perception begins with understanding the breadth and variability of symptoms and being aware of comorbidity.
More than a century has passed since the French neurologist Georges Gilles de la Tourette first described the condition that bears his name, a name familiar to the lay public and health professionals alike. Once considered so rare that neurologists might expect to witness the disorder perhaps once in their professional lifetime, Tourette syndrome (TS) is, in fact, common enough that virtually all pediatricians will have several patients with this condition in their practice. Yet, despite its name recognition and the number of people it affects, TS often goes undiagnosed or misdiagnosed. Misconceptions about this tic disorder are customary, with the syndrome often perceived as characterized by bizarre, fitful behaviors or comical outbursts of uncontrollable profanity.
Colorful descriptions of motor and phonic tics in literary characters (such as "Mr. Pancks" in Charles Dickens's Little Dorrit and "Captain Hardcastle" in Roald Dahl's autobiographical works1) and in historical figures (including the Roman Emperor Claudius, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, and 18th century English literary scholar Samuel Johnson) testify to the widespread awareness of TS across cultures and time, despite (or perhaps because of) its perceived rarity. So it seems that the medical community trailed the untrained community by centuries in recognizing the syndrome.
From the time of its initial medical description in 1885 until the 1960s, medical experts viewed TS as a psychological disorder, and treatment was customarily directed toward psychotherapy. In the 1960s, the observed benefit of psychotropic medications in alleviating tics reformed this perception, proving a clear neurologic basis to the phenomenon. That discovery has prompted a wide range of research-based interest in understanding and classifying this varied disorder.
The tics of TS range widely in their severity, form, frequency, and intensity. Moreover, although tics are the hallmark of diagnosis, TS is associated with a range of comorbid conditions. When present, these conditions are usually more serious or disabling than the tics themselves.
The pediatrician can be most helpful to a child with TS by recognizing signs and symptoms early in onset. The diagnosis of TS (the focus of Part 1 of this two-part article) and its management (the focus of Part 2) depend on recognizing the unique clinical presentation of each child and directing an ongoing comprehensive and supportive care plan.
(Table 1, "Diagnostic criteria for Tourette syndrome," reprinted in the print issue with permission from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Text Revision, Copyright 2000 American Psychiatric Association)
Recent studies suggest that ticsmostly transient, lasting less than one yearoccur in 20% or more of schoolchildren.2 Tourette syndrome, in which the tics are chronic, may occur in 1% or more of mainstream children, with a higher prevalence still among children with special education needs.3,4
The clinical manifestations of TS are extremely diverse, and no two patients present identically. Most have mild tics; the minority is severely affected. Tics are repetitive, sudden, involuntary or semivoluntary productions. They are customarily classified as "simple" or "complex" and as "motor" (movement) or "phonic" (sound-producing). Tics may appear to be exaggerated fragments of ordinary motor or phonic behaviors that occur out of context.5
TS is the most severe tic disorder, marked by both motor and phonic tics. Chronic tic disorders other than TS are characterized by motor tics only or, less commonly, by phonic tics only. Chronic motor tic disorders occur more commonly than do TS, but follow a course similar to that of TS in terms of tic progression and comorbid affliction. The following discussion refers specifically to TS.
So-called simple tics involve a single muscle or functionally related group of muscles, and are generally brief, lasting less than a half second each. However, simple tics may occur in repeated bouts of rapid succession, each bout lasting seconds or more. What are known as complex tics involve more muscle groups, often have a more sustained duration or orchestrated pattern, and may appear purposeful. Complex phonic tics more clearly involve linguistically meaningful speech and language than do simple phonic tics. Table 2 lists examples of simple and complex motor and phonic tics.
|Motor tics||Eye blinking Nose wrinkling Jaw thrusting Facial grimacing Shoulder shrugging Wrist snapping Neck jerking Limb jerking Abdominal tensing||Hand gestures Jumping Touching Pressing Stomping Facial contortions Repeatedly smelling an object Squatting Deep knee bends Retracing steps Twirling when walking Unusual posturing (e.g., a frozen position, such as holding the neck in a particular tensed position for one or more seconds) Copropraxia (a sudden, tic-like vulgar, sexual, or obscene gesture) Echopraxia (imitation of someone elses movements)|
|Phonic tics||Sniffing Grunting Barking Throat clearing Blowing Coughing Snorting Chirping Clicking Sucking sounds Screaming||Single words or phrases Speech blocking (e.g., stuttering or other interruption to speech fluency) Meaningless changes in pitch, emphasis, or volume of speech Palilalia (repeating ones own sounds or words) Echolalia (repeating the last-heard sound, word, or phrase) Coprolalia (inappropriate expression of a socially unacceptable word or phrase, such as an obscenity or specific ethnic, racial, or religious slur)|
The words "phonic" and "vocal" are often used interchangeably in the TS literature when describing oropharyngeal and nasopharyngeal noise-producing tics. Strictly speaking, a vocal tic is produced by the vocal cords; so, some phonic tics (such as sniffing) technically are not vocal tics. Though somewhat controversial, it is within accepted clinical practice to include phonic tics like sniffing in the vocal tic category.
Tics typically appear in early childhood (most often by 6 or 7 years), initially as simple motor tics, followed by phonic tics and more complex motor tics usually within the ensuing two years or so, although sometimes not until early or middle adolescence. At onset, motor tics usually are simple in nature, with fast, darting, and purposeless eye blinking or neck movements being the more common ones. Over months or years, motor tics may become increasingly complex, involving more areas of the body, generally progressing over time in a top-to-bottom and central-to-peripheral direction. In addition, the movements may become more elaborate or sustained and include combinations of movements, such as touching or tapping, hopping, or holding unusual postures, such as an outstretched neck, eyes deviated to one side, or other dystonic posturing. Motor tics may also be self-injurious to the skin (scratching oneself, frequently licking the lips resulting in severe chapping, or pulling out one's hair), mucous membranes (biting the inside of the cheeks), spinal, muscular, or orthopedic structures (violent head-jerking, bending, or muscle straining), or vision (poking at the eyeballs).
Similarly, phonic tics usually are simple at onset, and are generally meaningless noises, such as coughing, grunting, or barking. Over time, more complex phonic tics may appear, and can include palilalia: repetition of one's own words, such as "How are you? You? You? You?" sometimes with an exaggerated volume or pace to the repeated words. Other complex phonic tics include echolalia (repeating someone else's words). Although widely associated with TS, coprolalia (the utterance of obscenities or other socially inappropriate remarks) occurs in only a minority of patients. Because of its sensational potential, however, this feature of TS is routinely exploited in media portrayals. The common misconception that coprolalia must be present for a person to have TS may delay or obscure the diagnosis.
Note that the distinction between motor and phonic tics may be artificial and misleading. Technically, phonic tics are motor tics, just ones that produce sound, and classification of some tics as motor vs. phonic is not universally agreed on (e.g., a sniff or a tongue click). For now, at least, a phonic tic (present or past) must be present for the condition to meet the definition of TS.
Because a picture speaks a thousand words, you can better familiarize yourself with the diversity of tics by viewing examples online at www.mdvu.org/multimedia/slides/ts/default.htm.
Tics generally occur daily, but typically wax and wane. This quality of increasing and decreasing frequency of tics is evident both in short-term and long-term segments of time. As such, tics usually are seen to have a fractal quality; in other words, tics may occur in bouts over seconds or minutes separated by periods of tic-free behavior lasting for seconds or minutes. The bouts themselves may occur in bouts over hours, such that there are bouts of bouts. That pattern may continue for days, months, or longer. (Figure 1, "Bouts of tics take on a fractal character over time," sourced in the print issue from: Leckman JF, Peterson BS, King RA, et al: Phenomenology of tics and natural history of tic disorders. Advances In Neurology ? Tourette Syndrome 2001;85:1-14).
Many people with TS describe a "premonitory urge" or sensory discomfort in a muscle or muscle group preceding the tic, which builds over time.6 This urge may be described as tension, pressure, a tickle, an itch, or another sensory experience. The urges are sometimes described less as a physical sensation than as a psychic phenomenon, such as anxiety or anger. External stimuli, such as a noise, a word, or an image, can provoke this urge in some patients. Performing the tic results in temporary relief. Patients often describe a sensation of needing to have the tic feel "just right" to achieve relief. A single tic may bring relief for some people (or, for a particular person, some of the time), whereas for other people (or at other times) a rapid succession of repeated tics or orchestrations of tics is required. In the case of self-injuring tics, the sense of relief may be possible only once pain is experienced, although such pain is very distressful to the person.
Children younger than 10 years typically are unable to identify these urges. For patients who do describe awareness of an urge, tics can usually be suppressed to some degree, particularly as the person grows older (i.e., as a child reaches adolescence). To this end, tics may be said to be voluntary or semivoluntary in most patients with TS. Some patients report that, were there no sensory urge, they would not tic. However, voluntary suppression comes at the cost of growing discomfort and distraction caused by the unrelenting, unfulfilled urge. Tic suppression is disruptive and can be more debilitating than the tic itself. The suppression may interfere with a child's ability to focus and can increase anxiety. Tic suppression usually results in a rebound phenomenon at a latersafer, as it weretime and place (such as when the child returns home from school) during which the severity of the urges that had been suppressed compels more frequent and intense tics.
Stress, anxiety, fatigue, and other high-level emotional excitement exacerbate tics. Certain situations may reduce, or invoke suppression of, tics, such as settings or occasions where it may be embarrassing to ticvisits to the doctor's office or speaking with friends,7 for example. Tics usually do not occur during sleep, but are more likely to happen at times and places of personal relaxation, such as while watching television at home.
About 90% of patients with TS have one or more comorbid conditions8 (Table 3). These conditions are stand-alone diagnoses that occur more often in patients with TS than in the general population. Outward signs of comorbid conditions may not appear as dramatic as tics and may therefore be overlooked. Each of these conditions can follow its own natural course, both in onset and in progression or cessation.
Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder
Obsessive-compulsive behaviors or disorder
Learning differences or disabilities
Oppositional defiant disorder
More than half of TS patients will have comorbid attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). The presenting clinical signs of ADHD usually precede the onset of tics. Psychostimulant medication, such as methylphenidate, is often used to treat ADHD. As a result, there has been a longstanding misperception that psychostimulant medication causes or exacerbates tics (I will address this misperception in Part 2).
Features of ADHD may include hyperactivity and restlessness, difficulty with sustained focus and attention, and distractibility. Loss of impulse control is another common feature. Among TS patients, some impulsive tendencies may, in fact, be responses to premonitory urges, a kind of a complex tic. Manifestations can include nonobscene, complex, socially inappropriate behaviors,9 such as pointing out an unpleasant body odor or a flaw in someone's appearance. Children with comorbid ADHD are more likely to suffer greater psychosocial and academic consequences,10 and to have more disruptive or delinquent behavior, than are those without comorbid ADHD.11
Obsessive thoughts and compulsive behaviors occur in most children with TS. In about one quarter of these children, the thoughts or behaviors are so severe that they disrupt normal function or cause anxiety, and constitute obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). It may be difficult to discriminate complex tics from compulsive behaviors. Some behaviors may appear more tic-like (such as evening things up, touching something over and over until it feels "just right," or creating symmetry in surrounding objects) for which the unofficial term "compultics" (compulsions that look like tics) has been coined. Other behaviors may appear more like obsessions (such as a fear of contamination leading to repetitive or excessive hand washing) and typically cause significant emotional distress. Still other behaviors may appear to be a fusion of an impulsive behavior and a tic, such as the urge to touch a hot flame or stare at the sun, for which the unofficial term "impulsion" has been coined.
Learning disorders, especially in math and written language, are also common comorbid conditions. Intelligence is distributed normally among children with TS, but learning disorders prevent these children from functioning at their intellectual potential. One unifying feature of many learning disorders and of ADHD is executive dysfunctions. Executive functions describe goal-directed skills that allow us to use intelligence efficiently (organizing, planning, decision making, impulse control, social skills awareness, prioritizing). People with executive dysfunctions may appear scatterbrained or find themselves easily distracted despite attempts to concentrate. These people have difficulty with behavior that is governed by rules and do not easily learn to correct their behavior from past mistakes.
Tics and other comorbid conditions can impose learning difficulties above and beyond those caused by learning disorders. Examples include the interfering symptoms of ADHD; tics that hinder efficient thinking or functioning; strenuous energy spent suppressing tics; and obsessions focusing on irrelevant details or compulsions to perform functionless and time-consuming behaviors, such as counting to 10 every three sentences or rehearsing a song mentally before being able to answer each test question.
People with TS are prone to anxiety. Symptoms may include generalized anxiety, social phobias or other simple phobias, panic attacks, and sleep difficulties. Mood disorders are common and may include depression or dysthymia (chronic but low-grade depression), and, possibly, bipolar disorder. Episodic sudden and explosive rage attacks occur in a minority of patients with TS and may reflect an underlying neurologic disturbance or a severe effect of anxiety and mood disturbances. Both anxiety and depression may also be outcomes of stresses imposed by the emotional interference and stigmatizing of tics and comorbid conditions.
Sleep-related problems include increased arousal, prolonged wakefulness, and increased time to sleep latency,12 and are more likely in patients who have comorbid ADHD.
There is growing evidence that autism spectrum disorder may be a comorbid condition of TS, albeit an infrequent one.13
One of the most regrettable outcomes in children with TS is poor self-esteem. These children are often the target of mockery and bullying by peers, or punishment and humiliation by intolerant family members or teachers. Symptoms of ADHD, social skills difficulties, learning differences, and other comorbid aspects increase the likelihood of victimization.
(Figure 2, ?The exacerbating-remitting natural history of TS and its comorbid conditions,? reprinted in the print issue with permission from: Janovic J: Tourette?s Syndrome. N Engl J Med 2001;345:1184. Copyright 2001 Massachusetts Medical Society)
Tourette syndrome occurs in all cultures and races. Although a familial basis for TS is well established, its genetic basis remains unclear. What does seem clear is that the syndrome is not explained by a simple gene mutation. Instead, one or more major "susceptibility genes" are likely involved, probably of an autosomal dominant inheritance pattern, some genes with minor effect, others more influential.14 The interaction of these genes with possible environmental influences appears to determine just how the disorder is expressed. Influences may include male gender (TS is four times more common in males than in females) and prenatal or perinatal factors such as lower birth weight or nonspecific maternal emotional stress.
When both parents have a tic disorder or a related comorbid disorder such as OCD, the likelihood of the child having TS increases markedly. While high, the precise risk of developing TS (and/or comorbid conditions) among offspring of parents with TS and/or OCD is not established. An ongoing prospective study recently reported that young children (most from a large, multigenerational TS-linkage family) with two TS- and/or OCD-affected parents, observed for up to five years, were three times as likely to develop tics than children with only one TS- and/or OCD-affected parent.15 Another study showed 43% of young children with a parent or sibling with TS developed some tic disorder during a four-year prospective study.16
An important point is made with an adage borrowed from the field of asthma: "All that tics is not Tourette." Children with mental retardation, autism, or another neurologically-based developmental disability may have tics for reasons unrelated to the genes that cause TS.
One controversial and intriguing theory posits an immunologic trigger for tics and obsessive-compulsive behaviors. PANDAS, or pediatric autoimmune neuropsychiatric disorders associated with streptococcal infection, was first defined in 1998.17 The PANDAS theory proposes that antibodies produced against group A b-hemolytic streptococcal infection cross-react with critical tissue in the brain and result in abrupt onset or exacerbation of symptoms. Proponents of the theory draw mechanistic similarity with Sydenham chorea, a manifestation of rheumatic fever. Beyond the scope of this review, PANDAS is the subject of an excellent commentary by Singer and Loiselle.18
Children and adolescents with tics alone, and those with comorbid difficulties, are likely to feel embarrassed or ashamed. Parents may feel a blend of personal failure, fear, and anger. To reduce these perceptions, a sensitive, empathic, and accepting interviewing approach is essential when taking a history. It is usually helpful to interview older children and adolescents privately, as well as in the company of their parents, to build a trusting alliance. Interviewing parents alone can allow an opportunity to discuss the impact that their child's behaviors have on family or spousal relations. These approaches paint a picture of the broader, global experience of Tourette syndrome.
In taking the history and performing the physical examination, be mindful not only of tics but of clues to each of the comorbid conditions and considerations in the differential diagnosis (Table 4). The ability to suppress tics distinguishes the movements from other hyperkinetic movement disorders and is a useful diagnostic aid. Tics are seldom uncertain when observed directly. Exceptions include so-called compultics and impulsions, as described. Another exception is stereotypies, such as those seen in children with pervasive developmental disorder. Such behaviors may include orchestrated behavioral sequences with touching, tapping, spinning, or other actions. Unlike tics, stereotypies tend to be completely voluntary, intentional, and self-soothing.
Direct effects of a substance (e.g., neuroleptic agent)
Myoclonus (brief, simple, shocklike muscle contractions)
Spasms, including blepharospasm
Stereotypies (often seen in pervasive developmental disorder)
Transient tic disorder
Chronic tic disorder
For the most part, the physical examination will be unrevealing. The money is in the history.19 The medical history should be comprehensive and include prenatal and perinatal factors, developmental history, neurologic history (e.g., seizure, coordination, trauma, sleep, atypical development), and confirmation of adequate hearing and vision. Ask about a family history of tics or comorbid conditions.
It is likely that several tics, past and present, will not be recognized, either because they were never noticed or because they have been forgotten. Reviewing the list of common tics (Table 2) can help the patient and family recall overlooked tics, and may be particularly helpful in diagnosing TS when there is any doubt about a history of phonic tics.
A social history can include information about parenting and discipline, family stressors, friendships, bullying, abuse, temperament, and self-esteem. Psychosocial function can be facilitated through use of the Pediatric Symptom Checklist (www.dbpeds.org/pdf/psc.pdf, with scoring instructions at www.dbpeds.org/pdf/jellinek.pdf), available without cost.
Scholastic data, including aca- demic performance and behavior rating scales completed by teachers and parents, are vital in the initial assessment. Several of these scales are available free, such as the Vanderbilt Assessment Scales in the National Initiative for Children's Healthcare Quality ADHD Toolkit (www.nichq.org/resources/toolkit).
Commonly, tics will not be observed during the office visit. Remember that tics are often suppressible (especially in the practitioner's office), and they wax and wane. Some children will substitute more apparent tics with less apparent ones in the clinical setting, or will wait to release tics precisely when you are not looking at them. Others may disguise tics as seemingly purposeful movements, such as brushing hair out of the face in concert with a head jerking tic, sometimes referred to as parakinesias.
A careful physical examination may reveal telltale consequences of tics. These stigmata may include excoriated lesions on the skin from picking, ulcers on the buccal mucosa from biting, or circumoral chapping from lip-licking. The neurologic examination should be nonfocal in tic disorders, although "soft neuromaturational" signs may be present, such as ambidexterity or bedwetting beyond the age of 5 years.
Diagnostic laboratory, imaging, or electroencephalographic studies are not indicated in the evaluation for TS. On occasion, such studies may be indicated to rule out other specific diagnostic considerations when findings on the physical examination or history warrant further investigation.
Although the diagnostic criteria for TS are straightforward, the diagnosis is often missed. Misconceptions about the syndrome explain much of this oversight. Most of the items listed in the differential diagnosis are uncommon; tics are not. Also, consider other tic disorders, including a chronic tic disorder (identical to TS except that the ticspast and presentare motor or phonic tics, not both) or a transient tic disorder (identical to a chronic tic disorder but the tics last less than a year [and longer than four weeks]).
In the absence of a careful history and exam, tics should never simply be explained away by telling parents that their child "will outgrow them." When the tics persist, such ersatz reassurance may plant the mistaken belief that a nervous disposition is causing the tics, or that the child could stop the tics if only he or she really wanted to.
More often than not, presenting complaints will not be tics but rather complications of a comorbid condition. Complaints may include school failure, abdominal pain, or sleep problems suggesting depression; social skills problems; hyperactivity; or bedwetting. (Parents or patients may also misinterpret ticscomplaining of "allergies" because of eye blinking or sniffing tics, for example.) In such cases, be on the alert for tics. Consider having parents provide videotaped samples of the child having tics at home, or try to discreetly observe the child in the waiting area, where the child may be less likely to suppress the tics.
Some families of children with TS trek from physician to physician in search of an answer, and wait years before they are given a correct diagnosis. The understanding that the diagnosis brings to patient and family, and the chance to begin to truly manage the condition, is, for many who have or who live with someone who has TS, an incredible relief.
Dispelling misconceptions about Tourette syndrome and its diagnosis
1. Larner A: Three historical accounts of Gilles de La Tourette syndrome. ACNR 2003;3:26
2. Snider LA, Seligman LD, Ketchen BR, et al: Tics and problem behaviors in schoolchildren: Prevalence, characterization, and associations. Pediatrics 2002;110:331
3. Kurlan R, McDermott MP, Deeley C, et al: Prevalence of tics in schoolchildren and association with placement in special education. Neurology 2001;57: 1383
4. Mason A, Banerjee S, Eapen V, et al: The prevalence of Tourette syndrome in a mainstream school population. Dev Med Child Neurol 1998;40:292
5. Leckman JF, Cohen DJ, Goetz CG, et al: Tourette syndrome: Pieces of the puzzle. Adv Neurol 2001;85:369
6. Banaschewski T, Woerner W, Rothenberger A: Premonitory sensory phenomena and suppressibility of tics in Tourette syndrome: Developmental aspects in children and adolescents. Dev Med Child Neurol 2003; 45:700
7. Silva RR, Munoz DM, Barickman J, et al: Environmental factors and related fluctuation of symptoms in children and adolescents with Tourette's disorder. J Child Psychol Psychiatry 1995;36:305
8. Freeman RD, Fast DK, Burd L, et al: An international perspective on Tourette syndrome: Selected findings from 3,500 individuals in 22 countries. Dev Med Child Neurol 2000;7:436
9. Kurlan R, Daragjati C, Como PG, et al: Non-obscene complex socially inappropriate behavior in Tourette's syndrome. J Neuropsychiatry Clin Neurosci 1996;8:311
10. Brand N, Geenen R, Oudenhoven M, et al: Brief report: Cognitive functioning in children with Tourette's syndrome with and without comorbid ADHD. J Pediatr Psychol 2002;27:203
11. Sukhodolsky DJ, Scahill L, Zhang H, et al: Disruptive behavior in children with Tourette's syndrome: Association with ADHD comorbidity, tic severity, and functional impairment. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 2003; 42:98
12. Kostanecka-Endress T, Banaschewski T, Kinkelbur J, et al: Disturbed sleep in children with Tourette syndrome: A polysomnographic study. J Psychosom Res 2003;55:23
13. Baron-Cohen S, Scahill VL, Izaguiree J, et al: The prevalence of Gilles de la Tourette syndrome in children and adolescents with autism: A large scale study. Psychol Med 1999;29:1151
14. Pauls DL: An update on the genetics of Gilles de la Tourette syndrome. J Psychosom Res 2003;55:7
15. McMahon WM, Carter AS, Fredine N, et al: Children at familial risk for Tourette's disorder: Child and parent diagnoses. Am J Med Genet 2003;121B:105
16. Carter AS, Pauls DL, Leckman JF, et al: A prospective longitudinal study of Gilles de la Tourette's syndrome. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 1994; 33:377
17. Swedo SE, Leonard HL, Garvey M, et al: Pediatric autoimmune neuropsychiatric disorders associated with streptococcal infections: Clinical description of the first 50 cases. Am J Psychiatry 1998;155:264
18. Singer HS, Loiselle C: PANDAS: A commentary. J Psychosom Res 2003;55:31
19. Dooley JM, Gordon KE, Wood EP: The utility of the physical examination and investigations in the pediatric neurology consultation. Pediatr Neurol 2003;28:96
"If the brain were simple enough that we could understand it, we'd be so simple that we couldn't." So remarked Dr. Paul Greengard, winner of the 2000 Nobel Prize in Medicine or Physiology. No surprise, then, that the neurologic basis of TS is unclear. That uncertainty is reflected in inconsistent classifications given the condition: "Tourette syndrome" vs. "Tourette disorder." A syndrome describes a set of signs and symptoms without an identified cause, whereas a disorder suggests an understood cause and, often, a predictable course. What seems clear is that the underlying mechanisms for pathology in TS and its comorbid conditions are linked.
According to our current model for understanding the pathophysiology of TS, the problem lies in the area of neurotransmission. Normally, dopamine and other neurotransmitters regulate messages transmitted along an important brain circuit that includes the basal ganglia, prefrontal and other cortex regions, and thalamus.1 One of the primary functions of this circuit is to process and filter information that refines controlled movement, thought, judgment, and the learning of behavior sequences. In TS, messages that should be filtered out instead slip through, in part because of faulty dopamine regulation at critical points in the circuit.2 The failure of appropriate filtering disinhibits thoughts, intellectual organization, sensory experiences, and behaviors.
What bridges tics and comorbid phenomena is a so-called urge-relief cycle. The overlapping circuitry may result in sensory urges relieved by tics, cognitive obsessive urges relieved by compulsive behaviors, or a sense of urgency relieved by an impulsive act (like blurting out an answer or interrupting someone) or by another socially inappropriate behavior (such as making a sudden off-color statement or observation).3 Other related manifestations that involve overlapping brain structures can result in depression, executive dysfunctions (such as poor organizational skills or inefficient intellectual processes), or sudden loss of emotional control that may be expressed as rage.
TS is a neurodevelopmental disorder so, as the brain develops, the form of the disorder evolves. The consequence is an array of colorfully unique features that vary not only from person to person, but also within any affected individual over time. To capture the range of potential symptoms, it has been suggested that an alternative name for TS and related disorders would be "developmental basal ganglia disorder," implying a spectrum of disorders that may manifest as any or all of the behavioral phenotypes. Although it is essential that tics be present for a diagnosis, it is most reasonable to regard tics as one of several possible symptoms of this filtering disorder.
1. Swerdlow NR, Young AB: Neuropathology in Tourette syndrome: An update. Adv Neurol 2001;85:151
2. Mink JW: Neurobiology of basal ganglia circuits in Tourette syndrome: Faulty inhibition of unwanted motor patterns? Adv Neurol 2001;85:113
3. Sheppard DM, Bradshaw JL, Purcell R, et al: Tourette's and comorbid syndromes: Obsessive compulsive and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. A common etiology? Clin Psychol Rev 1999;19:531
Samuel Zinner. Tourette syndrome: More than just tics, part 1: Diagnosis. Contemporary Pediatrics August 2004;21:22.