What role for diagnostic testing in syncope?

Article

A retrospective review of approximately 170 children with new-onset syncope who visited a tertiary care center strongly suggests that diagnostic tests for this condition have a low yield and are very expensive. Investigators concluded, therefore, that such tests should be used principally to corroborate findings from the history and identify life-threatening diseases.

A diagnosis had been established in three quarters of the syncope patients, 4.5 to 18.7 years. Neurocardiogenic syncope accounted for 91% of all diagnoses. Overall, 663 tests had been obtained, at an overall cost of $180,128. The average cost for one patient was $1,055, and the cost of one diagnostic result was $6,928. Only 26 tests (3.9%) were diagnostic in 24 patients (14.2%), and tilt-testing accounted for almost half of diagnostic results. (Investigators considered test results diagnostic when an abnormal result correlated with the clinical diagnosis or a normal result was obtained during an episode of syncope.) The most common test was electrocardiography; 93% of patients had at least one ECG, but only one was diagnostic. Echocard-iography, which accounted for 14% of the total cost of testing, did not produce a single diagnostic result. Chest radiographs, cardiac catheterization, electrophysiology studies, and serum evaluations also were nondiagnostic (Steinberg LA et al: J Pediatr 2005;146:355).

Commentary Few tests for syncope bear fruit, but these authors aren't recommending that you abstain from all testing. Instead, proceed à la carte, selecting tests that are suggested by a careful history, physical exam, and screening ECG.

Recent Videos
Paul Kruszka, MD
Herbert Bravo, MD
Tina Tan, MD
Paul Kruszka, MD, MPH, FACMG
Stephanie Anne Deutsch, MD, MS, MSCR, FAAP
H. Westley Phillips, MD
David Turkewitz, MD
H. Westley Phillips, MD
David Turkewitz, MD
© 2024 MJH Life Sciences

All rights reserved.