CME: A practical approach to the child who limps

February 1, 2002

Limping takes many forms, and the cause is not always obvious. The keys to diagnosis are careful observation of the gait disturbance and systematic evaluation, especially high-quality radiographs.

 

A practical approach to the child who limps

Jump to:Choose article section...LEARNING OBJECTIVES Types of impaired gait What does the limp look like? Zeroing in on the cause of the limpCommon causes of limping in children A closer look at some limping children

By David R. Godley, MD

Limping takes many forms, and the cause is not always obvious. The keys to diagnosis are careful observation of the gait disturbance and systematic evaluation, especially high-quality radiographs.

Limping—a disturbance of normal locomotion—appears in many variations1­3: A limp can be subtle or pronounced, chronic or acute, and is not always easy to describe or understand.1,4­7 Some causes of limping, such as a fractured foot, are obvious; other causes—cerebral palsy (CP) or other associated movement disorders, for example—are less clear. Diagnosing a limp in a child can therefore be difficult, and misdiagnosis of a serious condition, such as developmental dysplasia of the hip, can cause trouble for everyone. In addition to difficult clinical challenges and liability issues, we all have to live with new paradigms of cost-containment and patient satisfaction. We are therefore uncomfortable at the thought of diagnosing a limp.

 

LEARNING OBJECTIVES

After reviewing this article the physician should be able to:

 

This article outlines a practical approach to evaluating the limping child, including case histories with examples of gait analyses. Systematic assessment will help you to accurately analyze and describe causes and mechanical categories of limping and arrive at a proper diagnosis and suitable treatment recommendations, thereby satisfying patients, parents, and consultants, as well as yourself.

Types of impaired gait

Five types of mechanical impairment of gait have been described by others: deformity-related gait, antalgic (painful) gait, stiff-joint gait, gait affected by neuromuscular weakness, and gait affected by unequal limb length.1,4,8,9 Limb deformity (knock- knee, bowleg) is the most obvious cause of limping.1,3,6 Deformities extensive enough to affect postural alignment and locomotion are clear to every clinician and therefore are not discussed here.

A child with antalgic limp—as from a lacerated sole—shortens the stance (with the foot on the ground) phase of the gait cycle on the affected side1,2,3,9 and hurries to unload his (or her) weight from the sore part. Joint stiffness also produces a readily apparent dysfunction,1,6,7,9 an example of which is the "peg leg" limp seen in a child with a fused knee. Leg-length inequality produces a teeter-tottering trunk sway as the child vaults on the long leg and steps down on the short one.1,3,5,9 A child with hemihypertrophy, which causes one leg to be noticeably longer than the other, is an example of this type of impairment.

Weakness from neuromuscular disease—such as polio, CP, spina bifida, or muscular dystrophy1,3,4,9— can produce complex mixtures of gait abnormalities such as toe walking, Trendelenberg lurch, hyperlordosis, and crouch.1­3,6­9 Describing them can challenge even the best experts in the gait laboratory.1,8,9 Fortunately, most weakness-related limping is both chronic and obvious; you may elect to refer a child with this type of gait impairment to a pediatric orthopedic surgeon.

What does the limp look like?

A common challenge for pediatricians is to evaluate a newly developed (or, at least, newly observed) limp in a previously healthy child. Describing the new-onset limp mechanically helps you deduce its cause.

The technique I recommend for evaluating a limping child is to observe the undressed child walking in a long private hallway (Figure 1, available in the print edition, adapted from Staheli LT: Torsional deformity Pediatr Clin North Am 1986;33(6):1373).10 Encourage the child to walk as normally as possible back and forth several times while focusing your attention on one particular element of gait at a time.1 Unhurried observation is the key to successful gait analysis, but note: A child's inability or unwillingness to walk is also significant. I have seen several children who had septic joints and a history of limping but who completely refused to walk because of pain after they had been brought into the office. (For another case of a child who refuses to walk, see the Pediatric Puzzler.)

Beginning at the foot, watch for range of motion, postural alignment, weight acceptance, cadence, coordination, and general fluidity of movement.1,3,6 Note how each element differs from the normal pattern, which usually can be seen in the opposite limb, and describe it. (For example, you might record in your notes "toe walks," "walks only on lateral border of foot," or "drags toes.") Observe each part of the limb (foot, knee, hip, trunk-spine) in similar fashion. Remember to examine the spine; problems such as diskitis, tumors, and fractures can manifest themselves as a gait abnormality.

When you have assembled a complete description of the child's gait disturbance, note the essential qualities of the gait and compare them with patterns that you recognize (Trendelenberg abductor lurch, antalgic limp, or short-leg limp, for example). Your gait analysis need not contain technical data or scientific jargon.1,8 Clarity is the goal: Simple, clear description of abnormalities in ordinary language (tiptoe, flatfoot, swayback, stiff knee) is preferable. Let the facts speak for themselves and do not worry too much about terminology. That being said, familiarity with common musculoskeletal terminology is still useful as a means to describe gait abnormalities, so a brief glossary appears below.11

Zeroing in on the cause of the limp

Identifying the cause of the limp (fractured tibia, septic hip, slipped capital femoral epiphysis) is the ultimate goal of your evaluation. Remember, limping is a sign of disease; it is not the diagnosis.6 By thoroughly describing a limp, we can identify a specific physiologic abnormality—such as stiff knee or short leg—but not necessarily its cause—infection or fracture, for example. Diagnosis depends, therefore, on pulling together information from the history, gait analysis and other physical findings (limited range of movement, swelling), radiographs, and laboratory data—specifically, a complete blood count (CBC) and erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR).

Although a thorough medical history and physical examination, including careful gait analysis, are your best diagnostic tools, you may occasionally need to confirm the diagnosis with more extensive testing—such as magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) or joint aspiration. Usually, however, the medical history and physical examination, plain films, CBC, and ESR will get you most of the way toward a definitive differential diagnosis in one of the following categories of gait disturbance: infectious, developmental, inflammatory, neuromuscular, traumatic, or neoplastic.

To help you establish the differential diagnosis, the table lists common causes of limping in children. This table is derived from an excellent review by Richards,9 who reminds us that the causes vary for different age groups. Categorizing the patient as toddler (1 to 3 years of age), child (4 to 10 years), or adolescent (11 to 15 years) can help you to recall possible diagnoses characteristic for certain ages, even though considerable overlap exists in these age-based categories: 9-year-olds do occasionally have a slipped capital femoral epiphysis, for example, and a teenager can have a septic hip. In addition, keeping in mind broad diagnostic categories such as infectious and traumatic reminds you to order appropriate studies—ESR for suspected pyoarthrosis and biplanar radiographs for suspected slipped capital femoral epiphysis.

 

Common causes of limping in children

 Cause
Age (yr)InfectiousDevelopmentalInflammatoryNeuromuscularTraumaticNeoplastic

Toddler (1–3)Septic arthritisHip dysplasiaTransient synovitis of hipCerebral palsyToddler’s fractureLeukemia
 OsteomyelitisClubfootJuvenile rheumatoid arthritisMuscular dystrophyChild abuse 

Child (4–10)Septic arthritisHip dysplasiaTransient hip synovitisCerebral palsyFractureOsteoid osteoma
 OsteomyelitisClubfootJuvenile rheumatoid arthritisMuscular dystrophyLegg-Calv-Perthes diseaseEwing’s sarcoma
  Discoid meniscus Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease Leukemia
  Leg length discrepancy   Eosinophilic granuloma

Adolescent (11–15)Septic or gonococcal arthritisHip dysplasiaJuvenile rheumatoid arthritisHerniated lumbar diskSlipped capital femoral epiphysisOsteogenic sarcoma
 OsteomyelitisTarsal coalition SpondylolisthesisOveruse syndromesEwing’s sarcoma
  Osteochondritis dissecans Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease Osteoid osteoma

 

Plain films remain the reference standard for orthopedic diagnosis.9 To avoid missing something, always insist on excellent orthogonal films of the entire bone of interest. It is easy to become too focused on an apparent source of trouble and accept what seem to be adequate films—only to discover later that the films (and you) missed the most diagnostically relevant part. Too often, for example, ankle films are read as normal when a tumor or fracture is actually located slightly more proximal than the films are capable of revealing.

To avoid such misses, always demand that films of a long bone clearly show anteroposterior and lateral views of the entire shaft and the joints at both ends. Films that fail to do this are analogous to a chest film that shows only one lung. Children's bones have many confusing growth plates and epiphyses, of course, so a tactic I often use to avoid error is to obtain comparison views of the opposite (healthy) extremity. Again, I emphasize: Even with the widespread availability of bone scans and magnetic resonance imaging, high-quality plain radiographs remain the essential imaging tool when evaluating a limping child.2,7,9

A closer look at some limping children

The following five cases provide examples of the diagnostic evaluation of children with varying causes of limping.

Case 1: A 13-year-old boy limping for six months. The boy began to complain in June of pain in the knee after soccer practice; he did not arrive for treatment until November. There was no history of a specific injury. The pain was vague and dull and did not prevent the boy from playing. His parents brought him to the office for evaluation after a school holiday because he was limping.

Physical examination showed that the patient lay with the affected leg externally rotated and somewhat flexed at the hip. The flexion- extension arc appeared normal, but the boy could not flex the hip without externally rotating the limb. He could not rotate the limb internally at all. No bruising or tenderness was evident, and the leg appeared normal.

Gait analysis showed an antalgic limp on the affected side with external rotation of the whole limb, shortening of the stance phase, and mild trunk sway (lurch due to abductor inhibition).

Radiographs of the hip showed curvature of the femoral neck, widening and irregularity of the capital femoral physis, and 30% slippage of the epiphysis off the posterior femoral metaphysis (Figure 2). The final diagnosis was slipped capital femoral epiphysis of the stable (chronic) type.

 

 

Case 2: An 8-year-old girl limping for three days. The girl had been playing in a duck pond 10 days earlier when she hurt her foot. She thought she had stepped on something, but her mother saw no bleeding or wound. When the child was seen in the office, she had been limping for three days but was not complaining much and had not been ill.

The physical examination was normal except for a 1.5-mm puncture wound beneath the fifth metatarsal head and a trace of cellulitis surrounding the wound.

Gait analysis showed antalgic gait on the affected side, shortening of the stance phase, and a marked tendency to bear weight only on the heel. Radiographs showed diffuse osteolysis of the fifth metatarsal head and a few tiny flecks of metallic foreign material overlying the bone (Figure 3). The diagnosis was Pseudomonas osteomyelitis of the fifth metatarsal.

 

 

Case 3: A 22-month-old boy limping for one week. The child had been playing with his cousins at a playground on Sunday afternoon, but none of them was aware of an injury having occurred. He fell asleep in the car on the way home, so his mother put him to bed. On Monday morning, the boy avoided standing on his right foot for the first few minutes after his mother got him up. Gradually, he began to walk on the foot, but not normally. His mother could see no bruise or swelling, and the child was not crying, so she decided to "wait and see." In a few hours, the child started walking better, so she continued to observe him.

Each day, the pattern was repeated: The boy would not walk at first, then gradually improved to almost normal by afternoon. Because he continued to walk tentatively, his mother brought him for a checkup a week after his afternoon on the playground.

Physical examination showed an apprehensive child who did not want to cooperate and preferred to stay in his mother's lap. He had no sign of injury—no bruise, swelling, or deformity—and no restricted motion of hip, knee, or ankle of either leg. He did seem a bit more fussy when the distal part of his right leg was touched, however.

Gait analysis showed toddler's gait with a slightly shortened stance phase on the right foot. Examination was difficult because the child would take only a few steps while reaching up for his mother.

Radiographs showed a faint, spiral, longitudinal, hairline, radiolucent crack in the distal part of the right tibial metaphysis, 3 cm proximal to the physis (Figure 4). The final diagnosis was toddler's fracture of the distal part of the tibial shaft. We find that children can tolerate some use of the affected limb despite this type of fracture because the fracture is so stable; symptoms are thus intermittent.

 

 

Case 4: A 7-year-old boy limping for four months. This boy had always been very active in sports, but his parents could not recall his having sustained any particular injury. They brought him to the office for a checkup because the soccer coach thought the child was limping. He had not been sick.

Physical examination showed a thin, wiry, energetic boy who appeared healthy and fit. He had no pain or deformity but showed somewhat restricted left hip motion. Rotation and abduction of the left hip were each 50% reduced. The left leg did not appear shorter than the right.

Gait analysis showed graceful swaying of the trunk on the affected side, slight shortening of the stance phase, and dipping or lurching of the trunk toward the left.

Plain films showed gross flattening of the left capital femoral epiphysis, with sclerosis typical of avascular necrosis (Figure 5). The final diagnosis was whole-head type Legg-Calvé- Perthes disease.

 

 

Case 5: An 11-year-old boy walks "funny." The boy's father brought him in for examination because he had been "walking funny" for several years. He had no history of physical trauma or clinically significant illness. Gait analysis revealed a grossly obvious limp manifested by vaulting over the left leg and stepping down (as into a hole) on the right leg.

Physical examination showed an apparently healthy child who was limping. Scoliosis was apparent when the child was standing, and tape measurement showed his right leg to be 3 cm shorter than the left.

Results of a neurologic examination were normal, and all joints showed full range of motion. The left leg felt slightly warmer to the touch than the right leg, but the skin appeared normal.

Radiographs showed normal-appearing physes and bony architecture, but scanograms confirmed 3-cm shortening of the right leg: Half the shortening was in the femur; half, in the tibia (Figure 6). The final diagnosis was hemihypertrophy of the left leg as a result of deep-seated arteriovenous fistulae.

 

 

REFERENCES

1. Andriacchi TP, Hurwitz DE: Biomechanics of gait, in Beaty JH (ed): Orthopaedic Knowledge Update 6. Rosemont, Ill., American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons, 1999, pp 47-55

2. Phillips WA: The child with a limp. Orthop Clin North Am 1987;18(4):489

3. Tylkowski CM: Assessment of gait in children and adolescents, in Morrissy RT (ed): Lovell and Winter's Pediatric Orthopaedics, ed 3. Grand Rapids, Lippincott, 1990, pp 57­90

4. Adams FD: Physical Diagnosis, ed 14. Baltimore, Williams and Wilkins, 1958

5. Choban S, Killian JT: Evaluation of acute gait abnormalities in preschool children. J Pediatr Orthop 1990;10(1):74

6. DeGowin EL: Bedside Diagnostic Examination: A Comprehensive Pocket Textbook. New York, MacMillan, 1965

7. MacEwen GD, Dehne R: The limping child. Pediatr Rev 1991;12(9):268

8. Prior JA, Silberstein JS: Nervous system, in Prior JA, Silberstein JS (eds): Physical Diagnosis, ed 2. St. Louis, Mosby, 1963, pp 334­339

9. Richards BS: The limping child, in Richards BS (ed): Orthopaedic Knowledge Update—Pediatrics. Rosemont, Ill., American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons, 1996, pp 3­9

10. Staheli LT: Torsional deformity. Pediatr Clin North Am 1986;33(6):1373

11. Taylor EJ (ed): Dorland's Illustrated Medical Dictionary, ed 29. Philadelphia, WB Saunders, 2000

THE AUTHOR is chief of orthopedics at Kaiser Permanente's San Jose Medical Center, where he practices pediatric orthopedic surgery. Presented in part at: Wibbelsman C, moderator: Pediatric grand rounds: Orthopedics, April 9, 1999 (videotape). Oakland, Calif., Kaiser Permanente, Multimedia Communications, 1999.

A glossary of gait abnormalities

Ankylosis Joint immobility and consolidation caused by disease, injury, or surgical procedure

Antalgic Painful; posture or gait adopted to avoid pain

Apropulsive Lacking impetus, without push-off, lacking spring or energy

Ataxic Unsteady, lacking coordination, irregular

Broad-based Widened step pattern; a sign of poor balance

Cadence The rhythm or measure of walking

Calcaneus Heel; as in walking on the heel, with the ankle dorsiflexed

Cavus Deformity of the foot causing too high a longitudinal arch

Circumduction The circular movement of a limb; typical of hemiplegic spasticity in a stroke victim

Equinus On tiptoe; walking with the ankle plantar flexed

Fasciculations Fine or coarse twitching of small bundles of muscles; seen with progressive muscular atrophy and syringomyelia

Heel rise That portion of the gait cycle at which the calcaneus leaves the ground

Heel strike That portion of the gait cycle at which the calcaneus contacts the ground

Hypotonia Diminished tone or resistance of skeletal muscles

Kinematics The study of motion (of body segments, for example)

Kinetics The study of forces that produce movements

Knee motion Flexion and extension (extension = straight = 0°; full flexion = 140°)

Lean Trunk shift forward or backward

List Trunk shift to right or left; lateral bending to one side or the other

Lumbar lordosis Normal swayback; natural curve of the lumbar spine, making the concavity apex anterior

Pelvic motion Natural movements of pelvis: rotation, tilt, obliquity

Planus Flat; as in flat foot, deformity with too low a longitudinal arch

Rigidity Low-grade, steady contraction of agonist and antagonist muscle groups that results in stiffness; for example, rigidity caused by loss of extrapyramidal upper motor neurons in the basal nuclei of the brain (Parkinson disease rigidity)

Scissoring Crossing over of the legs because of adductor muscle spasm or contracture (seen in cerebral palsy)

Shuffling Slow, small steps made necessary by muscular rigidity; indicates extrapyramidal tract disease; if the person tries to move faster, shuffling becomes festination, an involuntary tendency to take short, accelerating steps (seen with Parkinson disease)

Spastic Muscle tightness caused by pyramidal tract disease, such as cerebral palsy or stroke; hypertonic muscles

Stance Definition phase of the gait cycle at which the foot is on the ground (60% of gait cycle)

Step length Length of stride while walking

Step width Distance from the line of progression while walking

Steppage Peculiarity of gait wherein person raises foot too high (because of weakness of ankle dorsiflexors), causing foot drop

Stiff Rigid, fused, ankylosed

Swing Definition phase of the gait cycle at which the foot is off the ground (40% of gait cycle)

Toe off Definition portion of the gait cycle at which the foot leaves the ground

Tremor Involuntary movement

Tremor, activity Coarse, polyrhythmic motions that occur with use of the part and that are worse at termination of movement; caused by disease of the cerebellar pathways

Tremor, athetoid Slow, writhing, twisting movements and grimacing

Tremor, choreiform Irregular, quick, brief movements of digits or face in constantly changing patterns

Tremor, myoclonic Abrupt, fleeting contractions of a muscle or group of muscles

Tremor, nervous Fine or moderate shaking (especially of the fingers) not accompanied by rigidity; caused by anxiety or nervous tension

Tremor, rest Coarse monorhythmic motions that lessen with use of the part and are accompanied by rigidity (Parkinson disease, senile brain deterioration)

Trendelenberg lurch Trunk shift over the affected hip caused by weakness of the gluteus medius (abductor weakness, abductor lurch)

Trunk shift Listing of the body to one side or the other of the center line

Va1gus Distal portion of the leg bent outward, as in knock-knee

Varus Distal portion of the leg bent inward, as in bowleg

Velocity Speed, rate, swiftness

Waddling Swaying from side to side (like a duck); toddling; teetering

Key points

Observe limping carefully, think systematically

  • Limping is a common sign of disease. It is not a diagnosis.

  • Limping has five, and only five, mechanical causes: deformity, pain, stiff joint, weakness, and short leg.

  • The differential diagnosis of a gait abnormality varies with the child's age.

  • Using careful observation and a systematic approach, the pediatrician can, in most cases, pinpoint the cause of a limp. Accurate diagnosis in a limping child requires a thorough medical history and physical examination; clear, complete radiographs; and a complete blood count and measurement of the erythrocyte sedimentation rate. More extensive studies, such as magnetic resonance imaging or a bone scan, are needed occasionally to confirm the diagnosis.

  • The best approach is to describe the child's limp mechanically and then by etiologic category.

ACCREDITATION

This activity has been planned and implemented in accordance with the Essentials and Standards of the Accreditation Council for Continuing Medical Education through the joint sponsorship of Jefferson Medical College and Medical Economics, Inc.

Jefferson Medical College of Thomas Jefferson University, as a member of the Consortium for Academic Continuing Medical Education, is accredited by the Accreditation Council for Continuing Medical Education to sponsor continuing medical education for physicians. All faculty/authors participating in continuing medical education activities sponsored by Jefferson Medical College are expected to disclose to the activity audience any real or apparent conflict(s) of interest related to the content of their article(s). Full disclosure of these relationships, if any, appears with the author affiliations on page 1 of the article and below.

CONTINUING MEDICAL EDUCATION CREDIT

This CME activity is designed for practicing pediatricians and other health-care professionals as a review of the latest information in the field. Its goal is to increase participants' ability to prevent, diagnose, and treat important pediatric problems.

Jefferson Medical College designates this continuing medical educational activity for a maximum of one hour of Category 1 credit toward the Physician's Recognition Award (PRA) of the American Medical Association. Each physician should claim only those hours of credit that he/she actually spent in the educational activity.

This credit is available for the period of February 15, 2002, to February 15, 2003. Forms received after February 15, 2003, cannot be processed.

Although forms will be processed when received, certificates for CME credits will be issued every four months, in March, July, and November. Interim requests for certificates can be made by contacting the Jefferson Office of Continuing Medical Education at 215-955-6992.

HOW TO APPLY FOR CME CREDIT

1. Each CME article is prefaced by learning objectives for participants to use to determine if the article relates to their individual learning needs.

2. Read the article carefully, paying particular attention to the tables and other illustrative materials.

3. Complete the CME Registration and Evaluation Form below. Type or print your full name and address in the space provided, and provide an evaluation of the activity as requested. In order for the form to be processed, all information must be complete and legible.

4. Send the completed form, with $15 payment, to:
Office of Continuing Medical Education/JMC
Jefferson Alumni Hall
1020 Locust St., Suite M32
Philadelphia, PA 19107-6799

5. Be sure to mail the Registration and Evaluation Form on or before February 15, 2003. After that date, this article will no longer be designated for credit and forms cannot be processed.

FACULTY DISCLOSURES

Jefferson Medical College, in accordance with accreditation requirements, asks the authors of CME articles to disclose any affiliations or financial interests they may have in any organization that may have an interest in any part of their article. The following information was received from the author of "A practical approach to the child who limps."

David R. Godley, MD, has nothing to disclose

 

CME REGISTRATION AND EVALUATION FORM

Date of publication: February 2002
Title: "A practical approach to the child who limps"
Author:
David R. Godley, MD
MP Code:
CP0202

Registration

Name: _______________________________________________   Degree: _______________

Street address: ____________________________   Institutional affiliation: ______________

City: _____________________   State: __________   ZIP: ___________   Telephone: __________

Specialty: [ ] Pediatrics   [ ] Other _________________ Years in practice: _________   Resident? ___

Time needed to complete this CME activity: [  ] <1 hr [  ] 1 hr [  ] 1.5 hr [  ] 2 hr

Certification: I attest to having completed this CME activity.

______________________________________
            Signature (required)   

Evaluation

1. Rate the overall effectiveness of this CME activity. 5 (very effective) 4  3  2  1 (not at all effective)

2. Circle "Yes" or "No"

YesNoA. The learning objectives were useful to me in determining whether performing this CME activity would be a worthwhile educational experience for me.
YesNoB. The objectives accurately described the content and potential learning value of this article.
YesNoC. This activity will influence how I practice medicine.
YesNoD. The activity was free from commercial bias.
YesNoE. I learned something new that was important from the article.

3. Which of the following best describes a change you might consider making in your practice as a result of something you learned from this activity? (Please circle only one response.)

A. Slightly modify what I currently do.
B. Make a major change in what I currently do.
C. Follow a procedure; use a technique/technology that is completely new to me.
D. Follow a procedure; use a technique/technology that I currently use but for a different purpose.
E. None of the above, but some change.
F. Not considering any changes.

4. Please describe any change(s) you plan to make in your practice as a result of this activity: ________

_________________________________________________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________________________

5. How committed are you to making these changes? 5 (very committed) 4   3   2   1  (not at all committed)

6. Other comments __________________________________________________________________

Payment

I am enclosing $15 to cover the cost of processing my CME application.
  [  ]  I am enclosing a check (payable to JMC/CME).
  [  ]  Please charge my Mastercard or Visa (circle type of card),

Account number: ___ ___ ___ ___ – ___ ___ ___ ___ – ___ ___ ___ ___ – ___ ___ ___ ___

Expiration date: ____ ____ / ____ ____.

                                          _____________________________________________
                                                              Signature (required)

 

David Godley. CME: A practical approach to the child who limps. Contemporary Pediatrics 2002;2:56.